UEFA’s deal with European Football Clubs faces EU competition complaint
The Union of European Clubs has asked the European Commission to investigate whether UEFA’s exclusive recognition of European Football Clubs shuts smaller teams out of decisions on competition formats, scheduling and revenue distribution.
The Union of European Clubs (UEC) has gone to the European Commission alleging that UEFA’s memorandum of understanding with European Football Clubs (EFC), which runs until 2033, breaches EU rules on anti-competitive agreements and abuse of a dominant position.The complaint centres on UEFA’s recognition of EFC as the sole representative body for European clubs and on its power to nominate 16 of the 20 members of UEFA’s Club Competitions Committee, which reviews proposed changes to tournament formats, qualification and prize money.UEC general secretary Dennis Gudasic said: “Today one association holds that mandate for all of Europe’s clubs, while most clubs have no effective voice in it. We are asking the Commission to examine whether that is compatible with EU law.”UEFA selects three committee members from its executive committee and European Leagues has one representative, while EFC also nominates two members of UEFA’s executive committee.The UEC is asking for the memorandum to be published and for binding changes to remove clauses it considers restrictive, although it says it remains open to talks with UEFA.Miguel Poiares Maduro, a former advocate general at the Court of Justice of the European Union who drafted the complaint, said: “The Court of Justice was clear in the Super League and other sports cases. Whoever controls access to European football must do so on transparent, objective and non-discriminatory terms.”The complaint argues that exclusive recognition of one clubs body fails that test, citing the court’s 2023 Super League judgment, which found that UEFA occupied a dominant position in the organisation of international club competitions and that its rules governing access had to meet those standards.The UEC says its own membership has grown to 138 clubs since its formation in 2023, surpassing the 100-club threshold it says UEFA had indicated would give it sufficient scale for recognition, but that UEFA has yet to recognise it or set out formal criteria.EFC, formerly the European Club Association, has more than 900 member clubs and approved reforms in September to expand its board to 33 members, while the UEC argues that many of those clubs still lack statutory voting rights or voting representatives on the board.UEFA president Aleksander Čeferin defended the arrangement when it was extended in 2024, saying: “Our partnership with the ECA is the foundation of an inclusive, sustainable and dynamic ecosystem that benefits the entire European football pyramid.”The complaint follows UEFA’s renewal of its cooperation agreement with the European Commission, which endorsed inclusive stakeholder governance, and comes as EFC examines whether to expand beyond Europe and establish a global clubs body.The filing asks the Commission to investigate the agreement and does not establish that UEFA or EFC has breached EU competition law.