Premier League clubs back legal protection for directors

Premier League clubs have approved broader legal protection for the competition’s directors after Manchester City sponsors Etihad Airways and Etisalat threatened legal action over findings in the club’s financial rules case.

brief

Premier League clubs have voted to extend legal indemnity for the organisation’s five directors, exposing all 20 member clubs to potential costs if Manchester City’s sponsors pursue claims against them.The proposal passed comfortably at a shareholders’ meeting in London, with BBC Sport reporting that Manchester City and Nottingham Forest opposed the amendment while the other 18 clubs supported it.Etihad Airways previously said: “The Premier League must take responsibility for the consequences of the way in which these findings have been presented. Etihad will seek the relevant legal counsel on the options and recourse available to protect its interests.”The airline and telecommunications company Etisalat have challenged findings concerning their sponsorship arrangements with City, published after an independent commission found the club guilty of 114 financial rule breaches in September.City deny wrongdoing and have appealed, with the hearing expected in December and any sanctions to follow if the findings are upheld.The league’s existing articles provided reimbursement of directors’ legal expenses when they successfully defended third-party proceedings, leaving them without equivalent protection if they lost.The approved amendment broadens that protection for chief executive Richard Masters, chair Alison Brittain and non-executive directors Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC.The collective arrangement means City would also share responsibility for covered legal costs arising from proceedings brought by their own sponsors.Etihad said it “categorically rejects any finding, conclusion or implication that suggests the airline has ever been involved in improper commercial arrangements”.Etisalat separately described the published findings relating to the company as “entirely false and defamatory” and said it was considering legal action.Neither company’s stated consideration of proceedings amounts to confirmation that a claim has been filed.The commission found that City used sponsorship arrangements it described as “sham” contracts to disguise additional funding from their Abu Dhabi ownership over a nine-year period.Masters said following the ruling that City had “systematically broken Premier League rules for nearly a decade”.According to BBC Sport, Forest’s opposition concerned the process for approving the amendment, including the information supplied and the time available to assess potentially substantial financial commitments.The club’s objection was understood to concern scrutiny of the proposal rather than support for City’s position in the financial rules case.BBC Sport also reported that City chief financial officer Ingo Bank asked whether the amendment directly followed the threats from Etihad and Etisalat, with Brittain declining to comment on that connection during the meeting.The vote required support from at least 14 clubs and changes the league’s arrangements for directors’ legal protection while City’s appeal and the sponsors’ consideration of legal action remain unresolved.